Top 10 St. Louis Blues of All Time

10) Ryan O’Reilly

Ryan O’Reilly’s tenure in St. Louis was relatively short compared to others on this list, but the impact he made was historic. Acquired in 2018, O’Reilly became the emotional and competitive engine behind the Blues’ first Stanley Cup championship in franchise history during the 2018–19 season. That playoff run alone cements his place in franchise lore. He scored 23 points in 26 playoff games and became the first player in NHL history to score in four consecutive Stanley Cup Final games while also winning the Conn Smythe Trophy as playoff MVP.

O’Reilly also won the Selke Trophy in 2018–19 as the league’s best defensive forward and was known for his unmatched work ethic and leadership in the locker room. His Game 7 performance in Boston, where he scored the opening goal in the Cup-clinching victory, is one of the defining moments in Blues history. Though his Blues career spanned only five seasons, his championship leadership and elite two-way play ensure his legacy in St. Louis will endure.

O’Reilly Mic’d Up

9) Alex Pietrangelo

Alex Pietrangelo holds a permanent place in St. Louis history as the first captain to raise the Stanley Cup for the franchise. Drafted fourth overall in 2008, Pietrangelo developed into one of the NHL’s premier two-way defensemen and captained the Blues from 2016 to 2020. His defining moment came in Game 7 of the 2019 Stanley Cup Final when he scored the second goal in Boston, providing critical insurance in the eventual 4–1 championship-clinching win.

During his Blues career, Pietrangelo played 758 games, scoring 450 points while logging heavy minutes in every situation. He was consistently relied upon to defend top opposing forwards while contributing offensively on the power play. His calm presence, skating ability, and positional intelligence made him the backbone of the blue line during one of the franchise’s strongest eras.

Pietrangelo’s leadership during the turnaround season of 2018–19—when the Blues went from last place in January to Stanley Cup champions—cemented his place among the franchise’s greats.

NHL Stanley Cup Final 2019: Alex Pietrangelo, St. Louis Blues hoist Stanley Cup | NBC Sports

8) Red Berenson

Red Berenson was one of the earliest offensive stars in Blues history. Acquired in 1967, Berenson quickly became a fan favorite for his scoring prowess and competitive fire. His most iconic performance came on November 7, 1968, when he scored six goals in a single game against the Philadelphia Flyers—still one of the greatest single-game performances in NHL history.

Berenson recorded 82 goals in his first full season with St. Louis and helped lead the franchise to three consecutive Stanley Cup Final appearances from 1968 to 1970. While the Blues fell short in those Finals, Berenson’s offensive production was critical to their early success. He totaled 195 goals in 511 games with the Blues and was selected to multiple All-Star Games during his tenure.

Even after leaving and later returning for a second stint, Berenson continued producing offensively into his mid-30s. His combination of scoring touch, leadership, and clutch performances made him one of the foundational stars of the Blues’ early years.

Memories: Red Berenson tallies six goals in a game

7) Mike Liut

Mike Liut was the stabilizing force in net for the Blues during the late 1970s and early 1980s. In the 1979–80 season, Liut led the NHL in wins with 32 and set what was then a franchise record for victories by a Blues goaltender. That season, he finished sixth in Hart Trophy voting—an extraordinary accomplishment for a goalie.

Liut’s best statistical season came in 1980–81 when he won 33 games and carried the Blues to a division title. That year, he earned First-Team All-Star honors and finished second in Hart Trophy voting behind Wayne Gretzky. He also won the Lester B. Pearson Award (now the Ted Lindsay Award), given to the league MVP as voted by the players.

Liut’s technical style and consistency made him one of the NHL’s top netminders during his prime. Though the Blues did not capture a Stanley Cup in his era, Liut’s elite play kept the team competitive and remains one of the most impressive goaltending stretches in franchise history.

Life as a Blue: Mike Liut

6) Chris Pronger

Chris Pronger delivered one of the most dominant single seasons ever by a defenseman in 1999–2000. Serving as team captain, Pronger scored 62 points, posted a league-leading +52 rating, and led the Blues to a franchise-best 114-point regular season. He won both the Norris Trophy as the league’s top defenseman and the Hart Trophy as league MVP that year—an almost unheard-of feat for a blueliner.

During his time in St. Louis (1995–2004), Pronger ranked second among Blues defensemen in goals, assists, and points, and first overall in franchise history in plus/minus. His physical presence, punishing style, and ability to control the pace of play made him one of the most intimidating players in the league.

Pronger was not just a bruiser; he was an elite puck-mover and power-play quarterback. His impact on both ends of the ice elevated the Blues to legitimate contender status throughout the late 1990s and early 2000s.

Chris Pronger Fights on the St. Louis Blues

5) Gary Unger

Gary Unger was one of the most consistent offensive producers in Blues history. From 1970 to 1978, he recorded eight consecutive 30-goal seasons, peaking with 41 goals and 83 points in 1974–75. His durability was remarkable—he famously played in 914 consecutive NHL games during his career.

Unger was selected to seven straight All-Star Games while with St. Louis and became the franchise’s first true ironman scorer. He totaled 575 points in 671 games as a Blue, providing reliable top-line production during a transitional period for the franchise.

Though the Blues did not achieve playoff dominance during his era, Unger’s steady scoring kept the team competitive. His ability to produce year after year without significant decline makes him one of the most dependable forwards in franchise history.

Garry Unger Highlight Video

4) Brian Sutter

Brian Sutter was the emotional heartbeat of the Blues throughout the late 1970s and 1980s. A three-time All-Star, Sutter played 779 games for St. Louis over 12 seasons, scoring 303 goals and 636 points—both totals ranking among the top in franchise history.

What separated Sutter was not just his scoring, but his grit and leadership. He amassed 1,786 penalty minutes, the most in franchise history, embodying a hard-nosed, physical style that defined Blues hockey for a generation. As team captain, he was known for his willingness to fight, hit, and score in crucial moments.

Sutter’s blend of toughness and skill made him a complete player. He later returned as head coach, further cementing his legacy within the organization. Few players have embodied the identity of the Blues quite like Brian Sutter.

Brian Sutter Highlights

3) Al MacInnis

Al MacInnis was one of the most powerful-shooting defensemen in NHL history. Acquired in 1994, MacInnis became the quarterback of the Blues’ power play for over a decade. He won the Norris Trophy in 1999 and was a two-time First-Team All-Star while in St. Louis.

MacInnis totaled 452 points in 607 games with the Blues and was a dominant presence from the blue line. His booming slap shot made him a constant threat and changed how teams defended the point.

Though he won his Stanley Cup in Calgary, his most sustained and impactful years came in St. Louis, where he served as captain and guided the franchise into the modern era.

Al MacInnis rode slap shot to Hall of Fame

2) Bernie Federko

Bernie Federko remains the franchise leader in assists (721) and points (1,073) in a Blues uniform. Playing 13 seasons in St. Louis, Federko was one of the NHL’s most creative playmakers of the 1980s.

He recorded nine consecutive 20-goal seasons and surpassed 100 points twice. Federko’s chemistry with Brett Hull during the late 1980s helped elevate the Blues’ offensive identity.

A model of consistency and offensive vision, Federko defined an era of Blues hockey. His number 24 hangs in the rafters as recognition of his enduring impact.

Bernie Federko – Highlights

1) Brett Hull

Brett Hull is the greatest goal scorer in Blues history and the most explosive offensive force the franchise has ever seen. In just 744 games with St. Louis, Hull scored 527 goals—still the franchise record. His 86-goal season in 1990–91 remains the highest single-season total in NHL history outside of Wayne Gretzky.

Hull recorded three 70-plus goal seasons and five 50-goal seasons with the Blues. He won the Hart Trophy in 1991 and was a two-time First-Team All-Star during his St. Louis tenure.

Though he won his Stanley Cup in Dallas, Hull’s prime was undeniably in St. Louis. His lethal one-timer and partnership with Adam Oates made the Blues must-watch hockey throughout the early 1990s.

No player defined offensive excellence for the Blues more than Brett Hull.

Brett Hull St. Louis Blues Highlights! The Golden Brett