
Tuesday, November 17, 2026 Time: 7:00 PM ET Location: UBS Arena — Elmont, New York TV: Blue Jackets Hockey Network / MSGSN Tickets: As low as $24 Records: Columbus 7-11-0 | New York Islanders 9-6-4 Current Moneyline: Islanders approximately -113 | Columbus approximately +108 Over/Under: 6 Goals
The Columbus Blue Jackets begin a four-game road trip Tuesday night when they visit the New York Islanders at UBS Arena desperately searching for a way to stop a four-game losing streak.
Columbus fell to 7-11-0 Saturday after a frustrating 4-3 loss to Philadelphia. The Blue Jackets jumped ahead 2-0 behind goals from Dmitri Voronkov and Matthew Knies, then watched the Flyers score four of the next five goals. Adam Fantilli tied the game during the second period before Denver Barkey scored the winner in the third.
The result continued a difficult stretch that includes losses to Buffalo, Florida, Tampa Bay and Philadelphia. Columbus has scored only seven goals across those four defeats.
New York enters moving in the opposite direction.
The Islanders completed a successful California swing Saturday by crushing Anaheim 6-2. Simon Holmström recorded his first career NHL hat trick, Matthew Schaefer collected three assists and Bo Horvat had a goal and an assist. New York has earned points in four consecutive games and has won two straight after previously going four games without a victory.
The Islanders also received an enormous lineup boost with the return of Mathew Barzal, who made his season debut Saturday after recovering from a knee issue. Barzal immediately recorded an assist on New York’s opening goal.
That additional offensive depth makes this a dangerous matchup for Columbus.
The Blue Jackets have shown flashes of quality hockey, but defensive mistakes have consistently erased good stretches. Against Philadelphia, Columbus generated enough offense to win but committed several costly turnovers, including one that led directly to Barkey’s deciding goal.
Zach Werenski described the situation accurately after the defeat: Columbus has reached a point where good efforts are not enough. The Blue Jackets need points before they fall too far behind in the Metropolitan Division.
The Islanders suddenly have several lines capable of generating offense.
Bo Horvat scored his ninth goal of the season against Anaheim and extended his point streak to four games.
Simon Holmström is even hotter. His hat trick gave him nine goals, and he has recorded three multipoint performances in his last four games.
Then there is teenage defenseman Matthew Schaefer, who enters on a five-game point streak after producing three assists Saturday.
Adding Barzal back to a group that already includes Horvat, Holmström, Kyle Palmieri, Anthony Duclair and Brayden Schenn gives New York considerably more depth than it had earlier in November.
Columbus cannot afford another game filled with defensive-zone turnovers.
If Columbus is going to break the losing streak, Kent Johnson, Adam Fantilli and Zach Werenski need to drive the offense.
Johnson entered the Philadelphia game leading Columbus with 17 points through 17 games, including eight goals and nine assists.
Fantilli scored his fifth goal Saturday and remains one of Columbus’ best players at generating chances through the middle of the ice.
Werenski continues carrying an enormous workload. Through 16 games he was averaging an NHL-leading 28:16 of ice time, while ranking among Columbus’ leaders in assists, points and shots.
The Jackets need that core producing because the forward group is dealing with injuries.
Conor Garland is on injured reserve with an upper-body injury, while Sean Monahan missed Saturday’s game after suffering an upper-body injury against Tampa Bay. Isac Lundestrom has also been sidelined.
Adam Fantilli — Columbus: Scored against Philadelphia and gives the Jackets their best combination of speed, size and finishing ability down the middle.
Kent Johnson — Columbus: Columbus’ early-season scoring leader and one of its most creative offensive players.
Zach Werenski — Columbus: The Blue Jackets’ most important defenseman, power-play quarterback and one of their most consistent shot generators.
Bo Horvat — New York: Enters on a four-game point streak and scored his ninth goal Saturday.
Simon Holmström — New York: Coming off the first hat trick of his NHL career and now has three multipoint performances in four games.
Matthew Schaefer — New York: The teenage defenseman is riding a five-game point streak and produced three assists against Anaheim.
Player-prop availability varies by sportsbook. These are recommended target lines if similar markets are offered.
Werenski plays more than 28 minutes on many nights and is heavily involved whenever Columbus is chasing offense.
Against an Islanders team playing well offensively, the Blue Jackets may need Werenski activating aggressively from the blue line.
Prediction: Werenski over 2.5 shots on goal.
Fantilli scored Saturday and should continue receiving opportunities in Columbus’ top six and on special teams.
His north-south style makes him one of the Jackets most likely to generate multiple shots.
Prediction: Fantilli over 2.5 shots on goal.
Horvat enters Tuesday playing excellent hockey.
He recorded a goal and assist in Anaheim and has produced at least one point in four straight games.
Prediction: Horvat over 0.5 points.
It is difficult to ignore Holmström’s current form.
His first NHL hat trick Saturday continued a stretch in which he has become one of New York’s most productive forwards.
Prediction: Holmström over 0.5 points.
Columbus’ most recent lineup had Jet Greaves and Cam Talbot as its goaltending tandem. Greaves started against Philadelphia and stopped 17 of 21 shots.
New York used Semyon Varlamov in Anaheim, where he made 26 saves in the 6-2 victory. Ilya Sorokin remains the Islanders’ other primary option. Tuesday’s starting goaltenders had not yet been officially confirmed.
The Islanders remain without Alexander Romanov, while Jean-Gabriel Pageau has been dealing with a lower-body injury. Barzal, Ryan Pulock and Matias Maccelli have recently returned, giving New York a much healthier lineup than it had a week ago.
Columbus will also be without head coach Rick Bowness at the beginning of the road trip while he undergoes additional medical testing. Assistant Don Granato has been running the bench in his absence.
Early consensus pricing makes this much closer than the teams’ recent form might suggest, with the Islanders around -113 and Columbus approximately +108. The consensus total is around 6 goals.
New York deserves the slight edge.
The Islanders are healthier, playing at home and have scored 11 goals during their two-game winning streak.
Columbus has enough offensive talent to make this competitive, but the Blue Jackets have repeatedly allowed one or two mistakes to determine games.
New York Islanders 4, Columbus Blue Jackets 2
New York Islanders Moneyline Zach Werenski Over 2.5 Shots on Goal Bo Horvat Over 0.5 Points Simon Holmström Over 0.5 Points
Columbus desperately needs a turnaround, but UBS Arena is a difficult place to find one against an Islanders team beginning to get healthy.
Barzal’s return gives New York another elite playmaker, while Horvat, Holmström and Schaefer are all entering the matchup in strong offensive form.
The Jackets should generate chances through Fantilli, Johnson and Werenski, but New York currently has more scoring depth and fewer major holes in its lineup.
Expect Columbus to remain competitive through two periods before the Islanders’ depth creates separation in the third.
Final Prediction: New York Islanders 4, Columbus Blue Jackets 2.
Current lines and player props can move substantially before Tuesday’s 7:00 PM ET puck drop. Confirm the starting goaltenders, final injury report and sportsbook markets before wagering.

21+ and present in OH. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
The sweepstakes and social casinos featured here are for adults aged 18 or over. No purchase is necessary to enter or win, and every operator offers a free way to get Sweeps Coins. Availability in Ohio varies by operator. Offers are subject to each operator's terms. Need a break? Call or text 1-800-MY-RESET (24/7) or visit https://ncpgambling.org. We may earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. This does not change how we review operators.