Powered by:
as known from New York Timesas known from USA Todayas known from yahoo!
Contains commercial content
The Grueling Truth - Where Legends Speak / The 10 Most Controversial Games in NFL Playoff History

The 10 Most Controversial Games in NFL Playoff History

Most controversial playoff games!
Publish Date: 01/19/2022
Fact checked by: Simon Briffa


10) 1979 AFC Championship game Houston at Pittsburgh

This is the game that started people screaming for instant replay; now this game would rank higher on the list, but with as great as the Steelers were I don’t think you can flat out say the Oilers would have one if they got the call. The play came in the third quarter of the 1979 AFC Title Game between the Houston Oilers and the Pittsburgh Steelers. Oilers receiver Mike Renfro made an amazing catch in the back of the end zone in the third quarter, but it was ruled that he did not get both feet in bounds (even though the replay showed he clearly had). Instead of a game-tying score, the Oilers continued to trail and ended up losing the game 27-13.

Video: One of the WORST Calls in NFL HISTORY: 1979 Houston Oilers vs. Pittsburgh Steelers - Mike Renfro

One of the WORST Calls in NFL HISTORY: 1979 Houston Oilers vs. Pittsburgh Steelers – Mike Renfro


9) 2002 NFC Wild Card N.Y. Giants at SF 49ers

The Giants were up by a seemingly safe 38-14 late in the third quarter, but a late rally by San Francisco brought it back. When the 49ers scored a touchdown with one minute remaining to take a 39-38 lead, it seemed little there was no hope for the Giants. However, Kerry Collins led his team down the field and put it into field-goal position to win the game.The snap was botched by veteran long-snapper Trey Junkin, and holder Matt Allen picked up the ball and heaved it downfield towards offensive guard Rich Seubert. Seubert was tackled on the play, which should have resulted in a pass interference call. However, the refs considered Seubert an ineligible receiver and called the incomplete pass the last play of the game. The Refs were wrong, and the game was given to the 49ers.

8) 1999 AFC Wild Card Buffalo at Tennessee

In this crazy Wild Card game, the Buffalo Bills were leading the Tennessee Titans 16-15 with only 16 seconds remaining in the game. What happened on the ensuing kickoff seems more likely to be the end of some unbelievable football movie. Tight end Frank Wycheck received the kickoff, ran to one side of the field and chucked a pass across the field to Kevin Dyson, who returned it for a 75-yard touchdown.

Where the controversy comes in is that many(myself included) thought Wycheck’s pass was a forward pass and should have been ruled illegal. Watch the reply and decide for yourself whether the pass was legal or not.


7) 1976 AFC Divisional Playoff New England at Oakland

This game always seems to get forgotten by Raiders fans when they are bitching about the “Tuck game.” The Patriots had blown the Raiders out in New England, and it would be the only blemish on the 1976 Raiders record as they would finish 13-1. The 1976 AFC Divisional Playoff matchup between the Raiders and the New England Patriots was tainted by a controversial roughing the passer call on the Pats Ray “Sugar Bear” Hamilton gave the Raiders new life down 21-17 late in the fourth quarter. Raiders quarterback Ken Stabler took the second opportunity and capitalized, running the ball into the end zone himself to give Oakland the 24-21 victory.


6) 1998 NFC Wild Card game Green Bay at SF 49ers

This game is known as the “Catch 2”, and it should never have happened. Jerry Rice probably the greatest WR in history hardly ever made a mistake in his career, but he did in this game. Now he did, in fact, catch a pass – it’s what he did after catching it that sparked the controversy in this matchup. Rice was ruled down near the end of the 1999 NFC Wild-Card game between the Niners and Packers, but replay showed that Rice had in fact fumbled and the ball should have belonged to Green Bay. Instead, the 49ers retained possession and the game ended with Steve Young throwing a game-winning touchdown to Terrell Owens with the final seconds ticking off the clock. The most amazing part of this whole scenario is the fact that it was Rice’s only catch of the game.


5) 1977 AFC Championship game Oakland at Denver

One of the several incidents that scarred Raiders fans for life during the 1970s was the Rob Lytle fumble incident – Lytle, a running back for the Broncos, immediately muffed a handoff during the third quarter of the 1977 AFC Championship Game, with the Broncos up 7-3. The ball came out as soon as Lytle was hit, but the referee ruled that his motion had already been stopped (by the officials). The Broncos kept the ball, scored on the very next play, and won the game 20-17. Much like the Rice play at number 5, this was not controversial; it was just a blown call.


4) 2002 AFC Divisional Playoff Oakland at New England

The Raiders were up by three with less than two minutes to spare. Tom Brady was looking to lead the Patriots down the field to at least attempt a field goal. Brady dropped back to pass, and Charles Woodson came on a corner blitz and got to Brady as he was about to throw. Brady dropped the ball, and the Raiders recovered. Game over, right?

The rest is history. The infamous “Tuck Rule” was implemented, the Patriots drove down the field, Adam Vinatieri kicked the game-tying field goal in a blizzard, and New England went on to win the game and eventually the Super Bowl.


3) 1972 AFC Divisional Playoff Oakland at Pittsburgh

Franco Harris’ “Immaculate Reception” is perhaps the single most famous play in the storied history of the Pittsburgh Steelers, but was it a legal play? No one knows, except the players that were directly involved and they might not even know! The issue at hand is whether or not the ball hit another Steeler before Harris caught it. Back then, a ball that hit a receiver (and was not caught) could not be caught in mid-air by a second receiver from the same team. The camera issue comes into play yet again, as there are few angles of the catch and none that show what the ball hit off of before Harris caught it.


2) Super Bowl 40 Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Seattle Seahawks

For conspiracy theorists who claim the NFL is fixed, this is the game to look at.This game is not remembered for one particularly bad call that changed the outcome of the game either way – it was a collection of calls that make Seahawks fans rue the mention of Super Bowl XL.

The referee who worked that Super Bowl, Bill Leavy, seemingly could no longer live with the guilt of that game and four years later proclaimed to the Seattle media that his officiating crew muffed several calls on that fateful night in Detroit.

Some of the calls that were blown included a questionable holding call while the Seahawks were on the verge of scoring, and a low block called against then Seattle QB Matt Hasselbeck for a low block (even though he was actually trying to make a tackle during an interception return), not to mention a few other phantom calls that included a shady pass interference call on Seahawks receiver Darrell Jackson.

Overall, it was a debacle – a pain that will never be alleviated for the Seahawks players who in all probability had a Super Bowl ring stolen from them that day.


1) 1965 Western Conference Playoff Baltimore at Green Bay

This was the most egregiously bad call of all-time. The Colts were a team that had lost not one quarterback but, both Quarterbacks. First, it was the legendary John Unitas because of a leg injury; then backup Gary Cuozzo with a shoulder separation. It meant that coach Don Shula had to find some replacement. He realized Tom Matte, a spirited halfback, had once played QB at Ohio State running the old split-T formation, which was not an exactly NFL offense, even back then.

Tom Matte, with only three days to practice for the role and wearing a wristband with a ready list of plays attached, Matte gave a remarkable performance against the Los Angeles Rams to clinch a tie for the Colts with the Packers, and force the one game playoff.

Now, a week later, it’s in Green Bay, still with Matte quarterbacking, and the Colts are leading 10-7 with less than two minutes on the clock. Chandler lines up to kick from the 22-yard line, attempting to gain a tie and force overtime. Chandler swung his right leg. The ball was high — and slicing.

Underneath the goal post, Referee Jim Tunney raised his arms. It was 10-10. But Colts Lou Michaels and Fred Miller, on the field-goal defending unit, were going crazy. They led the argument, screaming the kick had gone wide of the 10-foot-high upright. But it also was above the top of the post, meaning Tunney had to imagine if the ball was good, he imagined and unfortunately for the Colts he imagined wrong.

Chandler, dropped his head as if he had missed because he had! The NFL faced such backlash from the game that they ended up extending the uprights, but in the end, there is no doubt that this Lombardi Championship was severely tainted. Don Chandler to his credit admitted years later that he did indeed miss the kick.

Video: 1965 Western Divisional Round - Baltimore Colts at Green Bay Packers

1965 Western Divisional Round – Baltimore Colts at Green Bay Packers


Read Also
The 10 Biggest Upsets in NFL Playoff History: Which Upset was the Greatest?
I did not include Super Bowls in this ranking. These games were ...
The Greatest College Basketball Team of All Time
Rating the greatest college basketball teams ever has been done many times ...
Bet365 Promo
Edmonton Oilers, A Look ahead to an important off season
Rumours abound about free agency and draft and offseason trade markets, but ...
Come Fly with me: How the 1988-89 Chicago Bulls pushed forward to an NBA dynasty.
Find the best sportsbook to bet on the NBA Playoffs! Prologue: By ...
Esteban de Jesus, Roberto Duran y AIDS (1972-89)
Many of us dream of celebrity sports fame, but only cruel individuals ...
Michael Nunn and Iran Barkley Discuss Their Bout, Bob Arum, and the Four Kings
Mountains to Climb, Pebbles in Your Shoe “I always say that was ...
Grading every NFL team’s picks from the 2021 NFL Draft
Quickly, click away if you’re going to get upset by reading draft ...
Ranking the top 200 players in the NFL ahead of the 2021 season
This list isn’t based solely on performances from the 2020 NFL season. ...
Top 100 NFL free agents entering the 2021 offseason
Below is a list of the top 100 free agents available this ...
Sportsbook of the month
FanDuel - Get your Bonus Bet now! Get your Bonus Bet now!
Latest News
Top 10 Tight Ends in NFL History: Where do Kelce and Gronk Rank?
We have seen the Golden Age of Tight ...
Alabama Legislature Advances Bills for Sports Betting and Expanded Gambling
In a significant step towards legalizing sports betting ...
Milwaukee Bucks Stumble Against Memphis Grizzlies Ahead of All-Star Break
In an unexpected twist, the Milwaukee Bucks narrowly ...
Top 10 Most Overrated Coaches in College Football History
A week ago, I did an article on ...
Our Latest YouTube Videos
Video: Indiana Basketball Weekly W/Steve Risley: Indiana vs Iowa Recap and Penn State Preview!
Indiana Basketball Weekly W/Steve Risley: Indiana vs Iowa Recap and Penn State Preview!
Video: NFL Legends Show: Guest Former Bengals and Ohio State Running Back Pete Johnson
NFL Legends Show: Guest Former Bengals and Ohio State Running Back Pete Johnson
Video: Indiana Basketball Weekly: IU/Northwestern Preview W/Alec Lasley from Hoosier Illustrated!
Indiana Basketball Weekly: IU/Northwestern Preview W/Alec Lasley from Hoosier Illustrated!
Top Betting Sites
Top Betting Bonuses
DraftKings Review
FanDuel Review
BetMGM Review
Bet365 Review
Caesars Review
DraftKings Bonus
No Sweat First Bet up to $1,000
T&Cs apply
FanDuel Bonus
Bet $5 Get $150 in Bonus Bets
T&Cs apply
BetMGM Bonus
Bet $5 Get $150 Instantly in Bonus Bets
T&Cs apply
Bet365 Bonus
First Bet Safety Net up to $2000 OR Bet $5 and Get $150
T&Cs apply
At bet365 we don't do ordinary, that's why if you sign up now you'll get the choice of two great New Customer Offers, the First Bet Safety Net up to $2000 or Bet $5 and Get $150 in Bonus Bets. Deposit required. Bonus Bets wager excluded from returns. T&Cs, time limits and exclusions apply. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-Gambler 21+
Caesars Bonus
100% up to $1000
T&Cs apply
Our Team
Mike GoodpasterJosh SchwartzSimon BriffaMark LewisSamuel Teets
Mike Goodpaster
Mike Goodpaster
Chief Editor
Josh Schwartz
Josh Schwartz
Simon Briffa
Simon Briffa
Sports Editor
Mark Lewis
Mark Lewis
Samuel Teets
Samuel Teets
US Sports Veteran
Find out what the legends have to say about sports this week....
Find out what the legends have to say about sports this week....

Players must be 21 years of age or older or reach the minimum age for gambling in their respective state and located in jurisdictions where online gambling is legal. Please play responsibly. Bet with your head, not over it. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, and wants help, call or visit: (a) the Council on Compulsive Gambling of New Jersey at 1-800-Gambler or www.800gambler.org; or (b) Gamblers Anonymous at 855-2-CALL-GA or www.gamblersanonymous.org.

This site is using Cloudflare and adheres to the Google Safe Browsing Program. We adapted Google's Privacy Guidelines to keep your data safe at all times.

Players accepted in the US US Flag
Stake.us Exclusive Bonus
$55 Stake Cash + 260K Gold Coins + 5% Rakeback
Promo Code
Visit Site
T&Cs apply, 18+
Payment Methods
  • Exclusive promo code: TGTSOCIAL
  • Play Plinko, Hilo, Crash and more!
  • Get Stake Cash bonuses every day!
Stake Originals
Your Promo Code:
The bonus offer of was already opened in an additional window. If not, you can open it also by clicking the following link:
Visit Site