
UCLA has won 10 games in a row because it has won every game it has played. Alabama has eight wins and two losses. When the College Football Playoff committee meets again, I’d move the Bruins ahead of the Crimson Tide. Beating Illinois 22–14 gave UCLA another conference win and kept it alone atop the Big Ten. It also gave the committee a chance to show how much that record counts.
The last CFP rankings had Alabama third and UCLA fourth. Alabama beat Vanderbilt 21–6 on Saturday to improve to 8–2. Both teams took care of business, so anyone expecting an automatic reversal might be disappointed. The debate is about how the committee weighs the whole season when an undefeated team and a two-loss team keep winning.
Illinois didn’t score in the first half, but it stayed close enough to make UCLA work. The Bruins led 12–7 entering the fourth quarter and scored 10 points in the final period. The box score shows a game in which a couple of possessions could have changed the result. It also shows which team kept control when the margin tightened.
Illinois is 6–4 and beat Oregon earlier this season. That makes the result more valuable than it might look to someone who sees an eight-point margin over an unranked opponent and moves on. The Illini have shown they can make a good team uncomfortable. UCLA absorbed that challenge and got to 7–0 in league play.
A perfect record by itself doesn’t tell you whether a team can win a playoff game. What helps UCLA’s case is the way it has held up across different situations. The Bruins have won six home games and four road games. They’ve allowed 107 points in seven conference games. A defense that keeps opponents near 15 points per league game gives the offense a chance to win even when scoring is difficult.
Alabama went to LSU the previous week and won 31–13. It followed that with another road win, in which Vanderbilt managed only two field goals. The Tide scored two third-quarter touchdowns to separate after leading 7–3 at the half. Its defense controlled the margin even with the offense scoreless in the first and fourth quarters.
The best argument for the Tide is that a ranking should account for what a team has done against high-quality opponents and how well it has played in those games. A strong road win should carry real weight. The committee was willing to put Alabama third before the Vanderbilt game, and Saturday gave it no fresh loss to reconsider.
But the two losses have to carry weight, too. Alabama can present its best wins as evidence of its ceiling. UCLA can point to 10 games in which an opponent had a chance to beat it and came away without a win. That distinction should matter most when both teams play in major conferences and are separated by a single ranking spot.
Under this season’s format, the top four teams in the final rankings get first-round byes. If UCLA and Alabama stayed third and fourth, both would still be on the right side of that line. The order matters because another strong team can push its way into that group, and the team ranked fourth has less room to absorb it.
My ballot would have UCLA ahead of Alabama this week. The Bruins have done enough against conference opponents to earn that edge. If the committee holds Alabama above them, its explanation should identify which results it considers strong enough to make up for two losses. UCLA did its part against Illinois. At 10–0, the Bruins have earned a direct answer about what more the committee wants to see.
21+ and present in OH. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
The sweepstakes and social casinos featured here are for adults aged 18 or over. No purchase is necessary to enter or win, and every operator offers a free way to get Sweeps Coins. Availability in Ohio varies by operator. Offers are subject to each operator's terms. Need a break? Call or text 1-800-MY-RESET (24/7) or visit https://ncpgambling.org. We may earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. This does not change how we review operators.