
Texas moved from sixth to fifth in Tuesday’s College Football Playoff rankings. Notre Dame slipped from fifth to sixth. Both won on Saturday. The Longhorns escaped LSU 22–21 in Baton Rouge, while the Irish handled Boston College 41–7. Texas is 8–2. Notre Dame is 9–1. The debate is whether that latest road victory gave Texas enough to move ahead when the committee compared everything both teams have done.
Texas deserves credit for how it finished. Arch Manning found Raleek Brown for a four-yard touchdown with three seconds remaining. Texas had trailed by 11 in the second half, and its defense held LSU scoreless in the fourth quarter. Jelani McDonald intercepted three passes. The Longhorns needed contributions from their quarterback, defense and kicker to get out with a victory, and they got them.
Winning that game required composure. An offense facing a late deficit in Baton Rouge has to function through crowd noise, time pressure and the knowledge that one mistake can end the game. Manning delivered the decisive touchdown. The defense kept the opportunity alive. Those are meaningful parts of the evaluation, and Texas earned the right to have them discussed.
The same performance also gives the committee reasons for caution. LSU outgained Texas 366–273. The Longhorns rushed for 99 yards and needed the final seconds to decide the game. A win still counts fully, but the performance supplies a more complicated picture than a last-second touchdown highlight can capture. It shows a team capable of winning under pressure and one that had difficulty moving the ball consistently.
Notre Dame offered a different kind of evidence. Against Boston College, the Irish gained 500 yards and allowed 136. CJ Carr threw for 217 yards and two touchdowns. Notre Dame ran for 276 yards, with Jonaz Walton contributing 141. A Boubacar Traore strip sack became a Jaylen Sneed defensive touchdown. Boston College was 4–6 after the game, so this was an opponent Notre Dame should beat. The Irish did so convincingly across offense and defense.
The week before, Notre Dame had beaten Miami, which remains seventh in the committee’s rankings. That result should carry substantial weight in any comparison near the top. The Irish followed it with a dominant performance against a weaker opponent. Their latest game gave the committee little reason to question whether the Miami victory represented a team playing good football.
LSU’s status exposes the difficulty in explaining Texas’ promotion. The Tigers entered last week’s CFP list at No. 21 and fell out after losing to Texas. It is fair to credit Texas for helping cause that decline. It is also fair to reassess the Tigers as a 6–4 team. The committee needs to apply both considerations consistently when discussing the quality of a victory. Otherwise, a team can keep collecting credit for an opponent’s former ranking long after the opponent’s season has changed.
I would keep Notre Dame ahead. Its one-loss record and victory over a Miami team still in the top seven give it the stronger argument. Texas has a credible case based on winning a difficult road game, and its complete schedule deserves examination. But Saturday’s finish alone is insufficient to overturn the comparison. The committee should explain which parts of the full résumé put the Longhorns over the Irish.
The practical difference is visible in the current projection. Texas would host Boise State, with the winner advancing to face UCLA. Notre Dame would host Wake Forest, with the winner advancing to face Alabama. Those matchups can change over the remaining weeks, but seeding determines the route a team must take.
Texas earned its victory in Baton Rouge. Notre Dame earned another convincing win and already owns a victory over Miami. For me, the Irish’s season still adds up to fifth place. The committee’s next explanation should make clear why it reached the opposite conclusion.
21+ and present in OH. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
The sweepstakes and social casinos featured here are for adults aged 18 or over. No purchase is necessary to enter or win, and every operator offers a free way to get Sweeps Coins. Availability in Ohio varies by operator. Offers are subject to each operator's terms. Need a break? Call or text 1-800-MY-RESET (24/7) or visit https://ncpgambling.org. We may earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. This does not change how we review operators.