Seen on:
as known from New York Timesas known from USA Todayas known from yahoo!
OH

Jeremiah Smith vs. Malachi Toney: Why Miami’s Star Has a Case as College Football’s Best Receiver

Publish Date: 10/27/2026
Fact checked by: Mark Lewis
eremiah Smith deserves every bit of attention he receives. Ohio State’s star combines explosive production with an ability to turn important possessions into touchdowns.

Jeremiah Smith deserves every bit of attention he receives. Ohio State’s star combines explosive production with an ability to turn important possessions into touchdowns.

But the discussion about college football’s best receiver should no longer begin and end with him.

Miami’s Malachi Toney has built a compelling argument of his own. Through seven games, he has nearly matched Smith’s receiving yardage while catching considerably more passes. His latest performance—a school-record afternoon against Pittsburgh—demonstrated how thoroughly an offense can run through him.

My choice is Toney, narrowly, when evaluating the receiver I would want at the center of a college passing offense right now. Smith has the stronger argument for explosive production per reception. Toney’s case rests on the volume of successful plays he provides without sacrificing substantial yardage or touchdown production.

That distinction makes this a legitimate debate.

The Numbers Show How Close They Are

Through games played October 24, both receivers have appeared in seven games:

Smith’s totals are supported by his receiving statistics, while Toney’s season line reflects Miami’s completed game against Pittsburgh.

The comparison supplies a strong argument for each player.

Smith has produced slightly more yardage and one additional touchdown on 14 fewer receptions. That is an impressive efficiency advantage.

Toney has supplied more completed connections while finishing just 32 yards behind him. That suggests a receiver whose involvement can help an offense operate repeatedly, rather than depending primarily on a smaller number of substantial gains.

Neither statistical profile automatically establishes the better player. They show two different forms of exceptional production.

The Case for Toney Starts With Sustained Involvement

Catching more passes does not automatically make a receiver better. An offense can manufacture receptions that accomplish little.

Toney’s production makes that dismissal difficult.

His 66 catches have generated 952 yards and 11 touchdowns. Miami is getting meaningful returns from repeatedly involving him.

That is the foundation of the argument for Toney.

A receiver who can remain heavily involved gives a quarterback somewhere to return as a game develops. He can help maintain rhythm, supply opportunities when a defense changes its approach and turn repeated targets into productive possessions.

The qualification is important: reception totals alone do not prove route-running superiority, better hands or greater success against particular coverages. Those judgments require detailed film and assignment information.

What the numbers do establish is that Toney has handled a larger reception workload while remaining close to Smith in the categories that most directly damage a defense.

That deserves substantial weight.

Pittsburgh Showed How Much Toney Can Carry

Against Pittsburgh, Toney caught 16 passes for 194 yards and three touchdowns, setting Miami’s single-game receptions record.

The performance was remarkable for its combination of volume and finishing production.

Sixteen receptions mean repeated involvement across an afternoon. Three touchdowns mean that involvement extended to the scoreboard.

For Miami, Toney was a dependable source of offense and a player capable of delivering decisive gains. Pittsburgh could not prevent his repeated opportunities from becoming an overwhelming contribution.

One game should not decide this comparison. It should, however, change how seriously Toney’s argument is treated.

This was evidence that he can be the central receiving figure in a dominant offensive performance, even when the opponent has every reason to account for him.

Smith’s Explosive Advantage Must Be Respected

The strongest argument against choosing Toney is Smith’s production per catch.

At 18.9 yards per reception, Smith has generated substantially more yardage each time he completes a catch. His season also includes a 12-catch, 217-yard, four-touchdown performance against Illinois.

That kind of output can change a game quickly.

An explosive receiver creates pressure beyond the plays on which he receives the ball. Defenses must consider what happens if they leave him isolated or allow a coverage mistake.

Smith’s touchdown total also prevents this from becoming a simple argument about possession receiving versus empty deep yardage. He is finishing drives and scoring at an exceptional rate.

Anyone choosing Smith has a defensible position. His statistical efficiency is a major reason he remains such a strong Heisman candidate.

The case for Toney must acknowledge that advantage rather than pretend it does not exist.

Quarterback Play Makes Direct Comparisons Difficult

Both receivers benefit from talented quarterbacks and productive offensive structures.

Darian Mensah completed 31 of 37 passes for 387 yards and four touchdowns against Pittsburgh, illustrating the quality of the passing environment around Toney.

Smith has worked with Julian Sayin, whose injury now creates uncertainty around Ohio State’s passing offense. Sayin is sidelined indefinitely, with the Buckeyes preparing their backup quarterbacks for greater responsibility.

Those circumstances matter.

A receiver cannot control the accuracy of every target, the time available in protection or how frequently his number is called. Future production must be evaluated with those limitations in mind.

It would be unfair to downgrade Smith automatically if Ohio State’s passing volume or efficiency changes. It would also be unfair to treat Toney’s partnership with Mensah as a reason to dismiss what he accomplishes.

Great quarterback play and great receiving often reinforce each other. Giving one player credit does not require taking it from the other.

Why I Would Choose Toney Right Now

My preference comes down to the kind of contribution I value most when building a college passing game.

Smith offers the stronger demonstrated return per reception. Toney offers more repeated involvement while producing almost the same receiving yardage and nearly the same touchdown total.

I give Toney a narrow edge because that combination provides a compelling foundation for an offense. He can receive the ball frequently without his production becoming merely a collection of short catches.

That is an assessment of his current value, not proof that he wins every individual skill comparison.

I would not claim the available statistics establish that Toney is a better contested-catch receiver, a more complete blocker or a superior NFL prospect. Those are separate evaluations.

For the question of who deserves consideration as the better college receiver right now, however, his case is strong enough to make the choice.

Toney Has Earned More Than Second Billing

Smith remains an exceptional player with a résumé that can support a No. 1 ranking. His explosive production and touchdown frequency make any comparison demanding.

Toney has met that demand.

He has supplied more receptions, nearly identical receiving yardage and substantial scoring production. His record-setting performance against Pittsburgh strengthened an argument already supported by his season totals.

Smith may be the more explosive receiver per catch. Toney gets my narrow vote for the broader, sustained receiving contribution he is giving Miami.

The gap is small enough that November can change the answer. Through seven games, Toney has earned the right to be the answer—not simply the player mentioned after Smith.

Read Also
CJ Carr Takes Over as Heisman Race Favorite After Miami Win
CJ Carr was a long shot in the Heisman race a week ...
NCAA Week 10 No. 1 Miami at No. 4 Notre Dame 2026 Preview: Prediction, Betting Odds & 4 Prop Bets
One of the biggest games of the 2026 college football season takes ...
BetMGM Promo
Jeremiah Smith Breaks Big Ten Career Receiving Touchdown Record
Forty touchdown catches now sit next to Jeremiah Smith’s name, more than ...
Miami Is No. 1—but Georgia Just Made the Argument Much Harder
Miami won again. Georgia gave the country another reason to reconsider what ...
Ohio State’s Quarterback Problem Just Became a Championship Crisis
Ohio State can explain why its offense looked different Saturday night. Explaining ...
Ohio State vs USC Odds Favor Buckeyes on Saturday
Ohio State walks into the Coliseum on Saturday night as a 69% ...
NCAA Week 9 No. 1 Miami @ North Carolina Football Game Preview: Prediction, Betting Odds & 4 Prop Bets
Saturday, October 31, 2026 Time: 7:30 PM ET TV: ABC Location: Kenan ...
Top 10 Heisman Trophy Power Rankings: Jeremiah Smith Leads, Miami’s Stars Close In
The Heisman race has an unusual shape entering Week 9: three wide ...
Ohio State Still Hasn’t Named Its Quarterback—and USC Is Waiting
Ohio State has had a bye week to prepare for life without ...
Miami, Utah and UCLA Are the Last Unbeatens—Who Has the Strongest Case?
Three unbeaten teams remain in the Football Bowl Subdivision, and each has ...
Utah Is Unbeaten—but Houston Could Deliver Its Most Revealing Test
Utah has earned the attention that comes with a perfect record. Saturday ...
Ohio State’s Injury Problems Go Beyond Julian Sayin
Ohio State’s championship challenge now extends well beyond choosing a replacement quarterback. ...
Ohio State Beat Indiana—but Its Championship Chase Now Depends on Its Backup Quarterbacks
Ohio State left Bloomington with the victory it needed. It also left ...
Miami Survived Florida State—but Did It Look Like the Nation’s Best Team?
Miami has a strong argument for the No. 1 ranking this morning. ...
Latest Sport News
Arch Manning Leads Texas Past LSU 22-21
Arch Manning threw three interceptions, completed 19 of ...
Updated ESPN FPI Top 25 After Week 11
UCLA is 10-0, fourth in the College Football ...
CFP Rankings After Week 11: Indiana Belongs in the Top Five, Alabama at No. 9
The committee dropped Indiana five spots when its ...
Top 10 College Football Coaches on the Hot Seat After Week 11
Wisconsin looked like it had changed the conversation ...
Grant Wilson Gave Indiana’s Offense What It Had Been Missing
Grant Wilson’s first Big Ten start gave Curt ...
Utah Needed a 70-Yard Touchdown to Stay Perfect. What Did Arizona Expose?
Devon Dampier hit Creed Whittemore for a late ...
Top Betting Sites
Top Betting Bonuses
FanDuel
4.6/5
BetMGM
4.5/5
DraftKings
4.5/5
Fanatics
4.2/5
4.4/5
FanDuel
FanDuel Promo
New Users - Get $200 in Bonus Bets when you wager $5 for 4 days
T&Cs apply
4.6/5
Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or 1-800-MY-RESET. Visit www.mdgamblinghelp.org (MD). 1-888-789-7777 or ccpg.org/chat (CT). Hope is here. GamblingHelpLineMA.org or (800) 327-5050 for 24/7 support (MA). 1-877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY). 21+ (18+ D.C., WY) and present in select states (for KS, in affiliation with Kansas Star Casino). First online real money wager only. Min $5 wager required for 4 consecutive days. $5 first deposit required. Bonus issued as nonwithdrawable bonus bets which expire 5 days after receipt. Restrictions apply. See terms at sportsbook.fanduel.com. Call 1-877-770-7867 (LA).
BetMGM
BetMGM Promo
Get Up to $1,000 Back in Bonus Bets Over Your First 10 Days
T&Cs apply
4.5/5
Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or 1-800-MY-RESET (Available in the US) 877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY) 1-800-327-5050 (MA), 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA), 21+ only. Please Gamble Responsibly. Visit mdgamblinghelp.org (MD). See BetMGM.com for Terms. New Player Offer for new players only. Subject to eligibility requirements. Bonus bets are non-withdrawable. In partnership with Kansas Crossing Casino and Hotel. This promotional offer is not available in NJ, MA, MI, NV, NY, ON, PA, PR, and WV.
DraftKings
DraftKings Promo
Bet $5, Get $200 + 3 Months of NBA League Pass
T&Cs apply
4.5/5
GAMBLING PROBLEM? CALL 1-800-GAMBLER or 1-800-MY-RESET, (800) 327-5050 or visit gamblinghelplinema.org (MA). Please Gamble Responsibly. 888-789-7777/visit ccpg.org (CT), or visit www.mdgamblinghelp.org (MD), 1-800-981-0023 (PR). 21+ and present in most states. (18+ DC/NH/PR/WY). Void in CAN. Eligibility restrictions apply. On behalf of Boot Hill Casino (KS). Pass-thru of per wager tax may apply in IL. 1 per new Sportsbook customer. $5+ first-time bet req. Max. $200 issued as non-withdrawable Bonus Bets. Stake removed from payout. Reward issued as $50 in Bonus Bets every 7 days via click-to-claim for 21 days. Bonus Bets and click-to-claims expire 7 days (168hrs) after issuance. Terms: dkng.co/offer. Get 1 promo code to redeem a 3-month NBA League Pass subscription, complimentary of DraftKings. Subscription auto-renews monthly at then-current price (currently $16.99/mo); cancel anytime. Terms, restrictions, and eligibility requirements apply. Redeem League Pass by 12/19/26 at 11:59 PM ET. Addt’l terms: support.watch.nba.com/hc/en-us/articles/9165532876183-League-Pass-Terms-of-Use_. Ends 11/29/26 at 11:59 PM ET. Sponsored by DK.
Fanatics
Fanatics Promo
Get Up to $1,000 Matched in FanCash
T&Cs apply
4.2/5
Must be 21+. GAMBLING PROBLEM? CALL 1-800-GAMBLER OR CALL 1-800-MY-RESET, www.mdgamblinghelp.org (MD), (800)-327-5050 or gamblinghelplinema.org (MA), Call (877)8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY), (888) 789-7777 or ccpg.org (CT), morethanagame.nc.gov (NC), 1800gambler.net (WV)
Caesars Promo
Bet $1 and get double the winnings up to $25 for your next 10 bets
T&Cs apply
4.4/5
21+ New users only. Must register using eligible promo code. First bet after registration must qualify. Max. Bonus Bet: $1,000. Bonus Bet expires 14 days after receipt. Void where prohibited. See Caesars.com/promos for full terms. Gambling Problem? 1-800-GAMBLER (1-800-426-2537)
Our Team
Mike GoodpasterJames ErnestMark LewisJohn RaspantiMarvin Uzor
+5
Mike Goodpaster
Mike Goodpaster
Chief Editor
James Ernest
James Ernest
Author
Mark Lewis
Mark Lewis
Editor
John Raspanti
Author
Marvin Uzor
Marvin Uzor
Author
Daniel Kornhauser
Daniel Kornhauser
Author
Samuel Teets
Samuel Teets
US Sports Veteran
Ellis Williams
Ellis Williams
Author
Chris Benedict
Chris Benedict
Editor
Jon Adams
Jon Adams
Sports Writer

21+ and present in OH. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

The sweepstakes and social casinos featured here are for adults aged 18 or over. No purchase is necessary to enter or win, and every operator offers a free way to get Sweeps Coins. Availability in Ohio varies by operator. Offers are subject to each operator's terms. Need a break? Call or text 1-800-MY-RESET (24/7) or visit https://ncpgambling.org. We may earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. This does not change how we review operators.

This site is using Cloudflare and adheres to the Google Safe Browsing Program. We adapted Google's Privacy Guidelines to keep your data safe at all times.
CloudflareSSL
Close
Ready to Win Big? Join the Elite with Our Sports Betting Deals!
FanDuel
FanDuel Promo
New Users - Get $200 in Bonus Bets when you wager $5 for 4 days
Our Favorite
T&Cs and 21+ apply
Code:
Open FanDuel
Get Bonus
BetMGM
BetMGM Promo
Get Up to $1,000 Back in Bonus Bets Over Your First 10 Days
Best Slots
T&Cs and 21+ apply
Code:
Open BetMGM
Get Bonus
DraftKings
DraftKings Promo
Bet $5, Get $200 + 3 Months of NBA League Pass
Newcomer
T&Cs and 21+ apply
Code:
Open DraftKings
Get Bonus
Find out what the legends have to say about sports this week....
×
Your Promo Code:
The bonus offer of was already opened in an additional window. If not, you can open it also by clicking the following link:
Play now