
The committee dropped Indiana five spots when its opponents lost. Now three of Alabama’s best wins have lost some value, and the Hoosiers just beat No. 18 USC by two touchdowns.
Opinion | November 16, 2026
Last Tuesday, the College Football Playoff committee dropped Indiana from No. 4 to No. 9 during a bye week. On the same night, it moved two-loss Alabama from No. 5 to No. 3. A week later, Indiana is 9–1 after beating No. 18 USC 27–13, and Alabama is 8–2 after beating unranked Vanderbilt 21–6. If the committee applies the same logic it used last week, Indiana should be back in the top five and Alabama should slide to No. 9.
Selection committee chair Hunter Yurachek gave two reasons for Indiana’s fall. Teams around the Hoosiers picked up wins the committee valued, including Notre Dame’s victory over Miami and Alabama’s road win at LSU. He also pointed to six losses by Big Ten teams Indiana had played and said those results hurt the Hoosiers’ strength-of-record and strength-of-schedule metrics. The committee changed its assessment of Indiana’s season even though Indiana had played zero snaps that weekend.
Now look at Alabama’s résumé. The Tide had beaten three teams in the Nov. 10 CFP rankings: No. 11 Kentucky, No. 17 South Carolina and No. 21 LSU. On Saturday, Kentucky lost 21–14 to Florida, South Carolina lost 34–6 to Arkansas, and LSU fell 22–21 to Texas. LSU’s one-point loss to a top-six team is easier to defend than South Carolina’s 28-point defeat, and Kentucky and LSU remain ranked in Sunday’s Coaches Poll. Even so, all three results belong in the same weekly résumé review that sent Indiana tumbling.
Alabama deserves credit for winning on the road at LSU and Kentucky. Its 20–17 loss to Georgia also gives the committee a reason to think highly of the Tide. But Tennessee beat Alabama 26–10, and the Volunteers now have the same 8–2 record. When the committee put Alabama five spots ahead of Tennessee last week, it was already asking the résumé metrics to carry a lot of weight. With the Tide’s best victories taking a hit, the head-to-head result should carry more weight in that comparison.
Indiana and USC went into halftime tied 10–10. The Hoosiers outscored the Trojans 17–3 after the break and shut them out in the fourth quarter. Grant Wilson threw for 305 yards and two touchdowns, and Indiana intercepted Jayden Maiava twice on USC’s final two possessions. After Yurachek singled out Indiana’s offense as a point of discussion last week, the Hoosiers got a productive game from their quarterback against a ranked opponent.
Nobody in last week’s CFP top 10 who played lost, so a move to No. 5 would mean passing teams that also took care of business. That’s exactly the kind of comparison the committee made a week ago. Texas beat ranked LSU and Tennessee won on the road at Texas A&M. Those are credible cases to move up, and both teams have two losses. Indiana has one and just added a two-touchdown victory over a team the committee itself placed in the top 20. I’d put Georgia, Utah, UCLA and Notre Dame in the first four spots in some order, then put Indiana fifth.
Put Miami, Texas and Tennessee ahead of Alabama, and the Tide land at No. 9. A win over Vanderbilt keeps Alabama on solid footing in the playoff race. A win over USC gives Indiana a stronger case for a top-five spot. On Tuesday, the committee gets to show how much those two results matter when it weighs them alongside everything the teams’ opponents did.
21+ and present in OH. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
The sweepstakes and social casinos featured here are for adults aged 18 or over. No purchase is necessary to enter or win, and every operator offers a free way to get Sweeps Coins. Availability in Ohio varies by operator. Offers are subject to each operator's terms. Need a break? Call or text 1-800-MY-RESET (24/7) or visit https://ncpgambling.org. We may earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. This does not change how we review operators.