
Alabama remained No. 3 in Tuesday’s College Football Playoff rankings, holding a projected first-round bye at 8–2. Unbeaten UCLA stayed fourth. One-loss Notre Dame, Miami and Indiana sit sixth, seventh and eighth. Tennessee, which has the same record as Alabama and beat the Tide 26–10, is ninth. The committee has had another week to compare those teams, and its explanation needs to account for that six-place gap between Alabama and Tennessee.
A week ago, committee chair Hunter Yurachek explained Indiana’s fall from fourth to ninth by pointing to multiple factors. Other contenders won significant games, Indiana was idle, and losses by Big Ten opponents hurt the Hoosiers’ schedule metrics. That established a reasonable principle. A team’s résumé can change when the teams it has already played get better or worse. It also created an expectation that Alabama would receive the same review.
Kentucky, South Carolina and LSU all lost last weekend. They were three of Alabama’s wins over teams in the previous CFP Top 25. In the new rankings, Kentucky fell to No. 16, South Carolina to No. 21, and LSU disappeared entirely. Alabama retained two victories over currently ranked teams, so the claim that the Tide have zero ranked wins goes too far. The accurate criticism is that those victories have become less persuasive while Alabama’s position remains exactly the same.
There is a legitimate defense of Alabama’s résumé. The Tide won 45–17 at Kentucky, beat South Carolina 49–18 and won 31–13 at LSU. Those margins show Alabama controlled those games. Its 20–17 loss to Georgia was competitive against the team now ranked first. A committee comparing full seasons should consider all of that. The issue is whether those results justify third place, especially with a clear head-to-head defeat on the record.
Tennessee’s victory deserves more weight. A 16-point win gives the committee direct evidence about the two teams when they met. Schedule strength can help distinguish similar records, but the more weight it carries against that result, the more precisely the committee should explain the difference. Fans should be able to identify what Alabama accomplished elsewhere that outweighs Tennessee’s victory by enough to leave six places between them.
The win at Vanderbilt added little to the argument for that gap. Alabama won 21–6, but led only 7–3 at halftime and finished with 92 rushing yards on 35 attempts. The committee’s public explanation was that opponents’ losses had a smaller effect on Alabama’s schedule strength than on Indiana’s. That is a distinction worth examining. It needs numbers and comparative context to become a satisfying answer.
UCLA makes the ranking harder to defend. The Bruins have won all 10 games, and the Tide have lost twice. Schedule strength can justify placing a team with a loss above an unbeaten team, but two losses require a substantial difference in the quality of the wins. Alabama’s best results have just weakened. UCLA’s latest victory kept it unbeaten. At some point, the standings need to give meaningful weight to the difference between handling every assignment and losing twice.
Third place also comes with a tangible benefit. Under the current projection, Alabama skips the first round and awaits the winner of Notre Dame against Wake Forest. The teams behind the top four must win an additional elimination game. That makes the standard for awarding those four byes especially important.
Alabama has earned a place in the playoff discussion. Its victories over Kentucky, South Carolina and LSU support that. Third place demands a stronger case. With Tennessee holding the head-to-head result and UCLA still unbeaten, the committee should show exactly how its comparisons produced this order. The explanation has to be as clear.
21+ and present in OH. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
The sweepstakes and social casinos featured here are for adults aged 18 or over. No purchase is necessary to enter or win, and every operator offers a free way to get Sweeps Coins. Availability in Ohio varies by operator. Offers are subject to each operator's terms. Need a break? Call or text 1-800-MY-RESET (24/7) or visit https://ncpgambling.org. We may earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. This does not change how we review operators.