
Ohio State’s star receiver has the strongest case through Week 11. Utah’s Devon Dampier is making a late push, and Miami’s Darian Mensah still has the best passing résumé near the top.
November 17, 2026
Ohio State needed a win after back-to-back losses. With Luke Fahey starting at quarterback against Northwestern, Jeremiah Smith caught 11 passes for 117 yards and a touchdown in a 28–19 victory. Smith is up to 1,317 receiving yards and 15 touchdowns this season, and he’s scored in seven straight games. Ohio State has three losses, but Smith’s week-to-week production deserves its own judgment. He’d get my vote today.
Dieffenbach completed 13 of 20 passes for 232 yards and two touchdowns in UCLA’s 22–14 win over Illinois. His 54-yard touchdown pass to Aidan Mizell put the Bruins ahead early. When Illinois cut the lead to 12–7, Dieffenbach finished UCLA’s answer with a 26-yard touchdown to Semaj Morgan. The Bruins are 10–0, and those throws are a better argument for his inclusion than the record alone. He’ll need a bigger individual performance to climb into the finalist conversation.
Mestemaker’s 3,239 passing yards and 34 total touchdowns still earn him a spot. The problem is what happened when Oklahoma State had a chance to make a late-season statement against Texas Tech. Mestemaker threw for 277 yards but was intercepted twice, and the Cowboys lost 52–27. His full season keeps him on the ballot. At 6–4, Oklahoma State has fewer opportunities left for him to produce a performance that changes the race.
Toney had already banked 1,157 all-purpose yards when he was named a Paul Hornung Award finalist last week. His 234-yard, three-touchdown game at Stanford remains one of the best individual performances of the season. But he didn’t play against Duke, and Mensah threw for 382 yards in his absence. Toney’s versatility keeps him here. His case for a trip to New York would get a boost if he’s back on the field and producing down the stretch.
Russell threw for 217 yards and all three Alabama touchdowns in a 21–6 win at Vanderbilt. He also threw an interception. The three scores matter in a game where Alabama got all of its touchdowns through the air, but a comfortable win over a 4–6 team gives him little ground on the players ahead of him. The Iron Bowl gives him a bigger stage to build on a season that’s already earned him Maxwell Award semifinalist recognition.
Stockton threw for 252 yards and a touchdown and ran for another score against Missouri. Georgia built a 31–7 halftime lead, and Stockton was out of the game early in the fourth quarter. That’s a good Saturday for a quarterback on a 9–1 team. His opening to move higher is a game where Georgia needs him to make plays deep into the fourth quarter. The five ahead of him have either a stronger statistical case or a more memorable performance against a quality opponent.
Sheppard ran for 131 yards and two touchdowns, caught 12 passes for 93 more yards and broke Duke’s single-season rushing record against Miami. Duke lost 36–25, but Sheppard’s 224 yards from scrimmage explain why the Blue Devils stayed in it into the fourth quarter. He ran for 8.2 yards per carry, and his 12 catches show how much Duke leaned on him when it needed to move the chains. That’s a top-five performance against a playoff contender.
Carr followed Notre Dame’s win over Miami with 217 yards and two touchdowns in a 41–7 victory over Boston College. His only interception came on a tipped pass. The Miami game is still the centerpiece of his résumé, and he has only two interceptions all season. He’s fourth because the three ahead of him have done more to separate themselves individually. Saturday’s home finale against SMU is another chance for Carr to make the case that the Miami performance was a preview of his best football.
Mensah completed 30 of 41 passes for 382 yards in the win over his former team, Duke. He had no interceptions and found Javian Mallory for a 63-yard touchdown. Through 10 games, Mensah has thrown for 3,076 yards and 29 touchdowns against two interceptions while completing 76.3% of his passes. That combination of volume and efficiency gives him the strongest passing case on this list. If Miami gets to the ACC Championship Game, Mensah could have an extra opportunity to close the gap on Smith.
Dampier threw for 204 yards, ran for 100 and accounted for four touchdowns in Utah’s 40–39 win at Arizona. His 70-yard touchdown pass to Creed Whittemore supplied the winning points and kept Utah unbeaten. Mensah has the cleaner passing numbers. Dampier gets my edge this week because Utah needed both his running and his arm to survive a ranked opponent on the road. If the Utes reach the Big 12 title game unbeaten, he’ll have a chance to add another performance like it before voting.
Smith’s 117 yards accounted for more than half of Ohio State’s 201 passing yards against Northwestern. Even with a change at quarterback, he kept producing when opponents knew where the ball was likely to go. That’s the difference for me between Smith and the quarterbacks chasing him. A great quarterback can turn to someone else when his first option gets taken away. Smith has spent the season producing as the player defenses are trying hardest to take away. With Nebraska and Michigan left, he has two more chances to leave voters with a signature moment. He already has the season to win it.

21+ and present in OH. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
The sweepstakes and social casinos featured here are for adults aged 18 or over. No purchase is necessary to enter or win, and every operator offers a free way to get Sweeps Coins. Availability in Ohio varies by operator. Offers are subject to each operator's terms. Need a break? Call or text 1-800-MY-RESET (24/7) or visit https://ncpgambling.org. We may earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. This does not change how we review operators.