Today I want to discuss the top ten welterweights of all-time. You won’t find Roberto Duran on this list. I think Duran was a top 2 or 3 lightweight and maybe the best ever but his career at welterweight was very brief. Henry Armstrong is lower on the list than you would expect but, like Duran, I see Armstrong as a top 3 lightweight who would have had major problems with the size of the guys ranked above him.
10) Joe Walcott (Record: 92-25-24, 58 KOs)
Before there was “Jersey Joe” there was the “Barbados Demon”. Walcott beat 5 World champions – “Mysterious” Billy Smith, Rube Ferns, Dixie Kid, Honey Melody and Jimmy Gardner. Walcott amazingly fought a draw with legendary heavyweight Sam Langford and a draw with the great lightweight Joe Gans. Walcott fought all comers no matter what size they were and was fearless and heavy-handed. He was a true pioneer and seminal historical figure in the sport of boxing.
9) Thomas Hearns (61-5-1, 48 KOs)
Hearns was a great fighter but a lot of his success occurred at higher weight classes. He is on this list for his brief dominance in the welterweight division. Had Hearns not fought Sugar Ray Leonard, he would not be on this list. He actually out boxed the great Leonard and was winning the fight before getting knocked out after running out of gas in the 14th round of their first fight. Hearns beat some very good welterweight contenders such as Randy Shields, Bruce Curry and Harold Weston. His knockout of Pipino Cuevas in 1980 earned him Ring Magazine’s Fighter of the Year award.
8) Jimmy McLarnin (54-11-3, 20 KOs)
McLarnin faced 5 World Champions: Jackie Fields, “Young” Jack Thompson, Lou Brouillard, Young Corbett III and Barney Ross. A case can be made that he was at his best was at lightweight but he still faced a consistently faced a tough schedule in the ring. He retired at the young age of 29 and was inducted into the International Boxing Hall of Fame in 1991. McLarnin’s greatest victory was a win over the great Young Corbett III to win the title in 1933.
7) Henry Armstrong (151-21-9, 101 KOs)
As stated earlier in this article, Armstrong not only ranks as one of the top lightweights of all time but he was also one of the best welterweights ever. “Homicide Hank” only really fought 3 great welterweights in Barney Ross, Fritzie Zivic and Sugar Ray Robinson. He actually moved up to welterweight to win the title over Barney Ross between winning the featherweight and lightweight crowns. Undersized and often fighting below 140lbs while welterweight champion, Armstrong still defended the title 18 times over two years. I believe that Henry Armstrong was, pound-for-pound, one of the top 3 fighters of all time.
6) Jose Napoles (81-7, 55 KOs)
His best days may have been at lightweight also but it is hard to argue with a man that faced and beat 5 welterweight champions – Curtis Cokes, Emilie Griffith, Hedgemon Lewis, John Stracey and Billy Backus. Known as “Mantequilla” because he was smooth as butter in the ring.
5) Manny Pacquiao (57-5-2, 38 KOs)
Pacquiao has beaten a who’s who list of fighters including Oscar De La Hoya, Ricky Hatton, Miguel Cotto, Antonio Margarito and Tim Bradley just to name a few. He is not higher because he was knocked out by the great Juan Manuel Marquez. That is why he is rated below Mayweather at this moment. Of course, that of course can change May 2nd.
4) Barney Ross (72-4-3, 22 KOs)
A gifted boxer who became the first man to simultaneously hold the “Lineal Title” in three divisions simultaneously with the third coming when he beat the legendary Jimmy McLarnin to win the welterweight championship. Ross also beat the great Ceferino Garcia three times. He won 2 out of 3 against McLarnin and would go on to be an inaugural inductee into the International Boxing Hall of Fame in 1990.
3) Floyd Mayweather (47-0, 26 KOs)
Hard to rate an undefeated fighter any lower than this. There is the fact that in a win over Marquez, it was Marquez’ first fight moving up to 147 from 135. There are wins like the Ricky Hatton fight where it probably should have taken place a couple years earlier in the junior welterweight division. But, overall, majority of the Mayweather wins in the last few years have been against very good fighters.
2) Sugar Ray Leonard (36-3-1, 25 KOs)
In my opinion, the top two on this list are “no doubters”. Leonard, on his way to the title, beat almost every top contender possible. He won the title in 1979 over the great Wilfredo Benitez stopping Benitez at the end of the 15th round. That set up a fight with Panamanian legend Roberto Duran. Leonard stood toe-to-toe with Duran almost beating him at his own game. He lost a close decision but proved to everyone that there should be no doubt as to his bravery in the ring. In the rematch, Leonard moved, boxed and frustrated Duran to the point where, in the eighth round, Duran turned and walked away. Leonard’s toughness was unquestioned after his epic confrontation with Thomas Hearns. Trailing going into the 14th round, Leonard mounted a furious assault leaving Hearns battered and broken. The win cemented Leonard’s legend at welterweight.
1) Sugar Ray Robinson (173-19-6, 108 KOs)
This list is really Robinson and then everyone else. Robinson had an unbelievable record as a welterweight of 110-1-2! Robinson beat likes of Jake LaMotta, Marty Servo, Fritzie Zivic, Kid Gavilan and Henry Armstrong. To me, there should be no question that Sugar Ray Robinson was truly the best ever!