College Basketball Creighton vs Seton Hall: Preview, Prediction and Top Prop bets

Date: Thursday, March 12, 2026 | Time: 2:30 PM ET Location: Madison Square Garden, New York, NY | TV: Peacock / NBCSN

Betting Line: Seton Hall -3.5 | Over/Under: 137.5

The Matchup Context: Creighton’s Shooting vs Seton Hall’s Defense

The Creighton Bluejays men’s basketball team enters the Big East Tournament looking to extend its season after an inconsistent regular campaign. Head coach Greg McDermott has once again built a perimeter-oriented offense that thrives on ball movement and three-point shooting. Creighton averages over 75 points per game and can swing momentum quickly when their shooters get hot.

The Bluejays are led by senior guard Josh Dix, whose steady scoring and leadership have been crucial in close games. Creighton also relies heavily on shooters like Isaac Traudt and versatile forward Jasen Green, who provide spacing that can stretch opposing defenses.

Across the court, the Seton Hall Pirates men’s basketball team has built its identity around defense under head coach Shaheen Holloway. The Pirates finished the regular season with one of the best defensive units in the Big East, allowing just 65 points per game.

Seton Hall’s success revolves around interior toughness and physical rebounding. Guards like Adam Clark control the tempo offensively while big men such as Najai Hines anchor the defense with elite rim protection.

With Creighton’s shooting facing Seton Hall’s suffocating defense, this matchup presents one of the most intriguing stylistic clashes of the Big East Tournament.

Top 4 Prop Bets

Here are the Top 4 prop bets for today’s Big East Tournament matchup.

Prop Bet #1: Josh Dix Over 13.5 Points

Dix has been Creighton’s most consistent offensive weapon throughout the season.

In a matchup where perimeter scoring will be critical, the Bluejays will rely heavily on Dix’s ability to create offense against Seton Hall’s pressure defense.

EV Trigger: Strong value at 13.5 points.

Prop Bet #2: Adam Clark Over 5.5 Assists

Clark orchestrates Seton Hall’s offense and plays a major role in generating high-quality scoring opportunities.

Against a Creighton defense that prioritizes perimeter coverage, Clark should have multiple opportunities to distribute the ball inside.

EV Trigger: Playable up to 6.5 assists.

Prop Bet #3: Najai Hines Over 7.5 Rebounds

BetMGM

4.5/5

Tip: Najai Hines Over 7.5 Rebounds

• Rim Protector
• Interior Presence
• Rebounding Edge

Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win

Open BetMGM

Hines is a major reason why Seton Hall ranks among the best defensive teams in the conference.

Against a perimeter-heavy Creighton offense, there should be plenty of long rebounds available.

EV Trigger: Strong value if pace slows.

Prop Bet #4: Game Total Under 137.5

DraftKings

4.6/5

Tip: Under 137.5 Total Points

• Defensive Battle
• Slow Pace
• Half-Court Offense

New Customers: Bet $5+ Get $300 in Bonus Bets Instantly

Open DraftKings

Seton Hall prefers slow, physical games where defense dictates the tempo.

If the Pirates successfully limit Creighton’s perimeter shooting, this game could easily turn into a half-court defensive battle.

EV Trigger: Playable down to 134.

Keys to the Game

For Creighton to Win

• Hit early perimeter shots to stretch the defense • Move the ball quickly to avoid Seton Hall’s pressure • Limit second-chance opportunities

For Seton Hall to Win

• Control the tempo and slow the pace • Dominate the boards and protect the rim • Force Creighton into contested perimeter shots

Betting Odds & Analysis

Spread: Seton Hall -3.5 Total: 137.5

Creighton has the offensive firepower to make this game interesting, but Seton Hall’s defensive identity has been the difference-maker throughout the season.

If the Pirates control the glass and dictate tempo, they should have the advantage.

The Verdict

Prediction: Seton Hall 68, Creighton 65

Best Value Bet: Game Total Under 137.5

Expect a slow-paced, physical matchup with both teams fighting for every possession. Seton Hall’s defense and rebounding advantage should ultimately be the deciding factors in a tightly contested Big East Tournament battle.