Blue Jays vs Yankees ALDS Game 3: Top 4 Prop Bet Power Plays

The Toronto Blue Jays have stunned the baseball world by taking a commanding 2–0 series lead over the New York Yankees heading into Game 3 at Yankee Stadium. Toronto’s pitching and clutch hitting have silenced the Bronx crowd, while New York now faces elimination on its home turf. With urgency at its peak and both bullpens stretched, tonight’s prop market is loaded with sharp value on individual performances rather than the game total or spread.

Prop Overview

• Kevin Gausman (O 6.5 Strikeouts)

• Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (O 1.5 Total Bases)

• Aaron Judge (O 0.5 Home Runs)

• Bo Bichette (O 1.5 Hits + Runs + RBI)

Prop #1 – Kevin Gausman Over 6.5 Strikeouts

Toronto’s ace gets the ball with a chance to seal the sweep, and this spot fits him perfectly. Gausman’s splitter has baffled Yankee hitters all season — 22 strikeouts in 16 innings versus New York this year. The Yankees’ patient approach often leads to two-strike counts, where Gausman’s off-speed command takes over.

Why It Hits: New York ranks top-five in MLB strikeout rate vs right-handed pitching. Risk Factor: A short leash from John Schneider if the Jays sense early fatigue.

Prop #2 – Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Over 1.5 Total Bases

Vladdy is locked in. He’s recorded extra-base hits in both games of the series and looks dialed in against fastballs up in the zone. With the Yankees forced to use a bullpen game and no clear left-handed matchup to neutralize him, Guerrero should see pitches to drive early in counts.

Why It Hits: His barrel rate and exit velocity have spiked over the last month. Risk Factor: New York could pitch around him late if the Jays hold a lead.

Prop #3 – Aaron Judge Over 0.5 Home Runs

The Yankees’ season is on the line, and if anyone can keep them alive, it’s Judge. He’s 3-for-7 lifetime versus Gausman with two long balls, and his ability to adjust to the splitter has improved. The pressure and crowd energy could ignite one of those signature opposite-field blasts.

Why It Hits: Judge’s power numbers at home are elite — 1 HR every 9 ABs in the Bronx. Risk Factor: If the Jays pitch carefully, Judge may see limited hittable fastballs.

Prop #4 – Bo Bichette Over 1.5 Hits + Runs + RBI

While Vladdy grabs headlines, Bichette has quietly been Toronto’s heartbeat in this series. He’s making consistent contact, driving in runs, and setting the table at the top. His gap-to-gap approach works perfectly against Yankee pitching, and he’s cashing this combo prop in 6 of his last 8 games.

Why It Hits: Multiple scoring paths — a two-hit night or a single with RBI and run scored. Risk Factor: Reliever matchups could reduce plate appearances if Toronto leads big.

Final Thoughts

Toronto’s balance of clutch hitting and dominant pitching has them on the brink of sweeping the Yankees — a shocking scenario few predicted. Gausman’s strikeouts and Guerrero’s power headline tonight’s best values, while Judge’s desperation factor and Bichette’s steady contact create multiple angles for bettors. Expect emotion, fireworks, and urgency from the first pitch on.

Best Value Pairing: Gausman Over 6.5 K’s + Guerrero Over 1.5 TB Long-Shot Add-On: Judge to Homer + Yankees Win (+340 range)